notes on sweeney
- April 6th, 2008
- Write comment
getting rid of the opening ballad was a terrible mistake. as i said elsewhere, this is why, as talented a stylist as burton is, he’s a hack when it comes to actual dramaturgy.
consider, for a moment, the opening to henry V. the chorus sets the tone, introduces the ideas, creates context. he invokes the muse, and draws the listener in.
the ballad of sweeney todd very deliberately references one of the great (and few) bogeymen of our culture and sets it apart as a “tale” – with all the mythic and moral baggage of such a thing – and not just another of burton’s immersively scenic alternate realities. it’s *prologue*, in a classical manner, and wholly appropriate to sondheim’s goals.
the movie met expectations: it was exactly what i expected to see when i heard that tim burton was making it. it was exactly what one would expect the tim burton version of sweeney todd to be.
i am so, so damned tired of heavy color casts… especially “gloomy greyblue.” movies are not just photoshop in motion.
who knew johnny depp could sing? though it took a while for me to get used to sweeney not being a baritone.
some of the singing performances were not as crisp as i am used to for this work, and in places missed the rage. depp’s quiet, hoarse “at last, my arm is complete again” was clearly meant to be menacing, but just didn’t carry the force of it.
i think my favorite scene was “pretty women”, the first encounter between sweeney and judge turpin. it was the first time i’d seen the intimacy between them – their shared obsession and fate – so well expressed.
i appreciated the image of the boy, viewed as he kills sweeney at the end, with the makeup beginning to reflect sweeney’s own madness. it made vengeance a communicable disease.
less appreciated was the Pietà, which was merely obvious.
i love “a little priest” too much not to have been bothered by the edits. but i still got a huge smile out of it.
i didn’t think that turpin’s solos would make it in. i was right. just too kinky for the mass audience.
violence? are you kidding? cartoon blood, no viscera, swift dispatch? i want to see the director’s cut. maybe there’s something actually “disturbing” there. as it is, this was acceptable postmodern grand guignol.
nihilism, mass murder, rape, cannibalism…
